Skip to content
5 August 2026

Unrequited love: How to cope when feelings aren’t mutual

Delve into the intricacies of a friendship that persists after romantic feelings remain unfulfilled.

Unrequited love: How to cope when feelings aren't mutual

In the heart of Boston, a unique phone booth installation at the Boston Public Library has become a confessional for those seeking advice on matters of the heart. Among the voices seeking counsel is an individual grappling with the complexities of unrequited love and the delicate dance of maintaining a friendship with an ex-partner.

This person, who wishes to remain anonymous, shares a story that resonates with many: a relationship that began with promise but ended with lingering feelings and a friendship that feels more like a bittersweet reminder of what once was.

When friendship feels like a compromise

The individual in question met a woman a little over a year ago, and their connection blossomed into a romantic relationship. However, this woman was also in a long-term relationship with someone else, a dynamic that added layers of complexity to their involvement. Despite the challenges, they became romantically involved, only to find themselves navigating the aftermath of a relationship that didn’t quite end.

Now, they are both actively working to build a friendship, but the lingering feelings make this transition difficult. The woman in question occasionally flirts, adding to the emotional turmoil. The anonymous individual is trying to accept that a romantic reunion may never happen, but the emotional tug-of-war persists.

The advice from Meredith Goldstein

Meredith Goldstein, the voice behind the Love Letters phone booth installation, offers insightful advice to this individual. She imagines the scene: two friends at the library, one smiling outside while the other seeks solace in the privacy of the phone booth. Goldstein suggests that the anonymous individual is longing for another chance but is stuck in a limbo of friendship that feels more like a pseudo-relationship.

Goldstein advises taking a step back, allowing space for both parties to reset. She suggests that the anonymous individual needs time away from the woman to heal and move forward. This advice extends to the woman as well, who may need to reflect on what she truly desires in her relationships.

The importance of setting boundaries

Setting boundaries is crucial in this situation. Goldstein emphasizes the need for both parties to communicate openly about their needs and expectations. Taking a break from the friendship, even temporarily, can provide the clarity and space needed to move forward.

Goldstein’s advice is clear: be friends, but not yet. Have a talk about taking a beat, allowing both parties to heal and gain perspective. This approach can help prevent further emotional turmoil and pave the way for a healthier dynamic in the future.

Readers respond with their insights

The Love Letters column has sparked a wave of responses from readers who have faced similar situations. Their insights offer a range of perspectives on how to navigate unrequited love and the complexities of maintaining a friendship with an ex-partner.

One reader, AUNTTIGGYWINK suggests that the anonymous individual should move from friend to acquaintance, recognizing that if the woman truly wanted to resume a romantic relationship, she would make an effort. Another reader, ASH12345 emphasizes the importance of self-respect and moving on from someone who is not fully committed.

DDL314 advises the anonymous individual to take a break from spending time with the woman, focusing on healing and being open to new relationships. KWINTERS1 echoes this sentiment, suggesting that taking control of one’s own life and emotions is essential for moving forward.

These responses highlight the importance of self-care and setting boundaries in relationships. They offer a glimpse into the collective wisdom of those who have navigated similar emotional landscapes.

The Love Letters phone booth installation continues to be a beacon of support for those seeking advice on matters of the heart. It serves as a reminder that we are not alone in our struggles and that there is value in seeking counsel and sharing our experiences with others.

Author

Henry Anderson

Henry Anderson of Edinburgh, sharp-corporate in demeanour, famously argued to run a council budget deep-dive after a packed Holyrood briefing, choosing public-accountability over easy headlines. Prefers evidence-led interrogation of institutions and collects annotated maps of the Lothians as a private quirk.